Forbidden to Wander (Mane’ Tajawwul) & Habibi, by Susan Youssef

Experiences of an Arab American woman who travels to the West Bank and Gaza to meet and realize her identity and love.

Forbidden to Wander

A bright face, creative mind, and exceptional persistence culminate in Susan Youssef, director of “Forbidden to Wander”, and “Habibi.”
A must see!

In early spring 2011, I became acquainted with a new film listed as “the first fiction feature film set in Gaza in over fifteen years”. The film Habibi is a story of a couple’s love in a state where they are “forbidden to wander”. Unable to be physically one, they must devise means by which to unite in spirit and love. As I researched Habibi I read that the young director, Susan Youssef, began work on the film in 2002. Through her persistence, eight years of diligent filmmaking has materialized in the soon to release film Habibi. Further, in an effort to reach her ancestral roots and to better understand the restrictions placed on the people of the West Bank and Gaza she had traveled there in 2002. Youssef did not go alone; she took her professional camera! In the West Bank and Gaza, she traveled camera in hand, reflecting upon life for lovers trapped in a land where those who fall in love are constantly under curfew and observation. The result of her 2002 trip was the short film Mane’ Tajawwul translated Forbidden to Wander.

Film students will find this film an excellent preparatory tool. Class discussion may develop around Youssef’s filming techniques, her trials and tribulations as a novice director, her undaunted persistence and want to make the film or her practical challenges in dealing with the actors and peripheral groups or onlookers. Richly deep discussions may evolve, as viewers perceive what Susan learns about her field of endeavor and how she must reflexively adjust and stay undaunted. Finally, while Forbidden to Wander offers several valuable points of departure for debate and critique, it more importantly shows that while good filmmaking is often difficult and filled with obstacles, it is truly rewarding and achievable to those involved. Beyond this, filmmakers, especially independent filmmakers, offer venues for society to find out news, and to understand political, cultural and social issues. At a March 16, 2011 Gonzaga University screening of Forbidden to Wander (with select scenes from Habibi), Youssef remarks that when she arrived in Palestine in 2002 she lacked direction in envisioning Forbidden to Wander. She admits the film was a “student work.” However, this student designation also establishes it firmly as an inspirational learning tool for future and established filmmakers. One might say that its weakness becomes its strength. Susan Youssef is a true talent in independent filmmaking. Forbidden to Wander has screened at the Sundance Film Festival, the Museum of Modern Art in New York, and the National Museum of Women in the Arts.

Whether viewing Forbidden to Wander for personal enjoyment, reflection on how people around the world live, as a source of education, or as an exercise in how to use strategy to direct and produce your own film, Forbidden to Wander is an excellent choice.

Forbidden to Wander may be viewed as a foundation for both Youssef as a person and director, and her new feature film Habibi. With Habibi scheduled to open fall 2011, I suggest that viewers may appreciate and enhance the experience of a love story through viewing both films in tandem. Watch this young, persistent, creative director. She is sure to have a bright future. Susan is recognized by Filmmaker Magazine as one of the 2010 “25 New Faces” to filmmaking.

*Photo, compliment of Susan Youssef.

Malcolm L. Rigsby is a faculty member in the department of sociology at Henderson State University, Arkansas.  He is completing his Ph.D. abd, at Texas Woman’s University, Denton, Texas.  In 1979 he received his B.A.T. from Sam Houston State University, in History and Education with a minor in Sociology.  He holds his J.D. from St. Mary’s University School of Law (1989) and is a licensed attorney in Arkansas and Texas.  He is active in the independent review of documentary film.


About Malcolm L. Rigsby

Malcolm L. Rigsby, Ph.D., J.D. is a faculty member in the Department of Sociology, Human Services and Criminal Justice at Henderson State University, Arkansas. He received his Ph.D. in sociology, at Texas Woman’s University, Denton, Texas. In 1979 he received his B.A.T. from Sam Houston State University, in History and Education with a minor in Sociology. He holds his Juris Doctor (J.D.) from St. Mary’s University School of Law (1989) and is a licensed attorney in Arkansas and Texas. He is active in the independent review of documentary film as well as a free lance reviewer for Educational Media Reviews Online (EMRO) hosted by the libraries at the University of Buffalo. He is active in research of prisoner identity and transformation toward pro-sociality and desistance from crime.
This entry was posted in Film Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s